She Taught Me Touch
I grew up in an imaginary city. Some cities remain the same for decades, even centuries, but not mine. The grid of streets I lived on in northwest Detroit remains, but the neighborhood, the school, the park, the corner store, the incessant hum of traffic, the Tigers game wafting from every back yard on a summer evening, those are gone. As a result, my childhood seems to be a dream or a play whose set long ago burned down.
In my memory it’s always warm, an Easter morning. I am four, wearing a new yellow dress with a white piqué pinafore. I am standing beside her house, in the sharp smell of warm brick, the scent of new cotton, vinegary aroma of Easter eggs. My little brother, with his quiff of pale hair and his matching yellow suit, looks like a newly-hatched chick. In my basket is a pink stuffed rabbit; in his, a blue one. We are posing for pictures. Or maybe it’s a summer evening, shadows softening the outlines of my grandmother’s flowerbeds and making a blue oval in the shade of the oak tree. She is leaning back in an Adirondack chair, her small, narrow feet in their black lace-up shoes neatly placed side by side.
She wore rimless spectacles, cotton print dresses and aprons trimmed in rick-rack. She cooked pot roast on Sundays, and dotted her side tables with figurines and bowls of flowers. My memories of her are mostly tactile: her soft cheeks, her arthritis-cramped fingers, the soft cables of her yellow cardigan, the nubby surface of her green sofa cushions. I remember the sound of her voice as she moved from task to task but I don’t remember her opinions because she never weighed in on family discussions of politics or religion.
My parents embraced the aesthetic we now call mid-century modern—Mad-Men style, with its clean lines and rejection of clutter. At home, our chairs were covered in naughahyde. Biomorphic ceramic ashtrays were the only ornaments on our streamlined coffee table. My father, who had spent the war years in England, hung architectural engravings on the walls and read Evelyn Waugh.
My tall, elegant mother eschewed makeup, jewelry, lace and frills for herself and for me as well. I had a short haircut and wore sensible lace-up shoes with my school uniform. At special occasions like Christmas and birthdays, my grandmother always wore red nail polish, bright red lipstick, and pearls in her ears. By the end of the evening, I would have donned her earrings and her cardigan as well as a touch of the lipstick. In all the festive snapshots, I’m the short-haired kid in glasses, wearing pearl earrings, an over-sized cardigan, a smear of red blurring her big grin.
My grandmother’s way of life, rooted in a childhood on a Michigan farm, was very different from my parents’ austere urban modernism but to me it was a sensory paradise. I can still see the bright yellow tiles on her kitchen floor and the faded pinks of the cabbage rose print in her chintz-covered armchair. Once a rich auburn, her waist-length hair had greyed to a soft gold-pink. In the morning, I loved to watch her pin her braids into an oval at the back of her head. I loved to sit by her side, whatever the task. I can still feel the smooth weight of the dull gold cotton sateen that she used to sew the pleated curtains for her the bay windows. My grandmother and I stroked the gold sateen together, admired it, and made plans for every scrap.
Some of the left-over fabric would become pin-tucked throw pillows for her sofa, and a bit more would appear as an elegant opera coat for my doll, Lily Goldbell. On long summer afternoons, she’d weed and harvest fruits and vegetables in her long back yard that seemed to me a world in itself, with its raspberry patch, tomato plants bristling in the sun by the pungent compost heap, its goldfish pond in the shade of the huge oak tree, and nearer the house, beds of pink cosmas, snowy allysum, black-eyed susans, orange dahlias, gold-and-brown marigolds.
When the work was done, and the new potatoes were soaking in ice water, we would sit on the side of her bed and sort out the top drawer of her dresser, the scarves and gloves and jewelry boxes. Every object had a story, and as she told me the story, my grandmother and I would study the beads or try on the gloves with their three fanned lines of stitches, one for each long bone of the hand. I would hold a silk handkerchief to my cheek or run the beads through my fingers of the rosary I’d receive on my first communion. I’d touch the brooch waiting for my twenty-first birthday to my collar. I felt as if my grandmother’s dresser held my whole future safe behind its curved mahogany drawers.
Unlike her sisters, my grandmother had married young and never went to college. The newspaper sitting in a basket in her sun room was the only reading material in her house. She never asked about my grades or my reading level. I was a bookish little girl, proud of my spot near the top of my class, but I was always glad to leave my school accomplishments behind when I visited Grandma. Perhaps that was the reason I needed to check in with her frequently. I longed for the smells and sights of her kitchen, her knick-knack shelf, her embroidered hand towels and starched curtains. I begged to stop for a visit whenever we passed her street corner in the car, no matter how urgent my parents’ errand might be.
She always had time. When my mother, distracted with two younger children, was too busy to show me how to do up the buttons on my bride doll’s elaborate gown, Grandma would sit beside me, and together we would do and undo every tiny pearl bead, and then we would pin up the bride’s long hair and place her veil perfectly. Together, we stroked the delicate tulle and arranged its stiff folds.
When I was five, my grandmother taught me to crochet with white cotton thread and a steel needle. I am left-handed, so not only did she have to convey the complex movements to my short, fat fingers and short attention span, but also patiently transpose all the movements from the right side to the left. So gentle was her teaching method that without any struggle, I soon found myself making intricate doilies, much to the amazement and bewilderment of my mother. With my growing collection of doilies, I began to understand the geometry of radial symmetry as circles grew with the repetition of eight spreading petals. From that moment, working out my grandmother’s patterns for cotton stars, I learned that holding a needle and thread or a strand of yarn could become as natural as holding a pencil.
As my school years continued, I spent less time with my grandmother. Weekends were devoted to nature hikes with my two younger brothers and visits to art museums, softball games and old movies on television. I spent my after-school hours inhaling books in the local branch library, sneaking from the children’s room into the adult section, and curling up in a corner with Katherine Mansfield, Charles Dickens, and F. Scott Fitzgerald.
My grandmother became ill. The diagnosis was hardening of the arteries, but the symptom was an increasingly severe dementia. Her beautiful hair was cut short, and then her words stopped altogether. When she died I was fourteen on the cusp of fifteen, just out of my freshman year of high-school, self-centered, moody, and anxious to put all signs of childhood behind me. No longer interested in doilies, I was busy reproducing the latest mod styles on my new sewing machine. I wore pale-pink lipstick, and when I could get away with it, lavender eye shadow and mascara. Beyond a vague sadness on the day of her funeral, I didn’t grieve or even think much about my grandmother for years until one Saturday night when I was mid-way through college.
I was sitting at a movie theatre downtown with my roommates, watching the cult hit Harold and Maude. Ruth Gordon in her seventies looked naggingly familiar. Suddenly she opened a drawer, turning to her young co-star Bud Cortt, and said, “let’s see what we have here.” I began to sob and couldn’t stop until long after the closing credits rolled. Suddenly, I was back in my grandmother’s bedroom, poring over her dresser drawer, carefully smoothing each scarf, each pair of gloves.
At that moment, my link to my childhood was restored. The sights and sounds and especially the textures of my childhood came to life again. I connected, consciously, with my past. I understood that an essential part of me experiences the world, not through logic or reason, but through my senses. I remembered how satisfying it was to hold a skein of cotton in my hands, and I realized why I loved to knit.
Today, forty years later, knitting still connects me to my grandmother’s love of the actual, material world, her quiet acceptance of the rhythms of nature, her skill in manipulating needle and thread, and her rare ability to find eternity in a summer afternoon. The feeling of a strand of yarn comforts me in a way that no photograph can do. It’s a direct link to that unspoken, tactile connection, my wordless genealogy, that imaginary place I discover again every time I cast on and make a stitch.